2012S. 1813; Bingaman Amendment

Penalizing Private Enterprise Transportation Funding

2012 - U.S. Senate

Conservatives Oppose

Description

The Senate adopted the Bingaman amendment to the transportation bill that would punish states that lease toll roads to private operators by reducing their transportation funding. ACU supports states efforts to include private enterprise in government programs and opposed this amendment. The amendment was adopted on March 13, 2012, by a vote of 50-47.

50

Voted Yes

47

Voted No

3

Did Not Vote

Legislators · 100

LegislatorVote
Richard Shelby Conservative
Jefferson Sessions III Conservative
Lisa Murkowski Leftist
Mark Begich Leftist
John McCain III Conservative
Jon Kyl Conservative
Mark Pryor Leftist
John Boozman Conservative
Dianne Feinstein Conservative
Barbara Boxer Conservative
Mark Udall Leftist
Michael Bennet Leftist
Joseph Lieberman Leftist
Richard Blumenthal Leftist
Thomas Carper Conservative
Christopher Coons Conservative
Clarence Nelson Leftist
Marco Rubio Conservative
Saxby Chambliss Conservative
Johnny Isakson Conservative
Daniel Inouye Leftist
Daniel Akaka Leftist
Mike Crapo Conservative
James Risch Conservative
Richard Durbin Leftist
Mark Kirk Did Not Vote
Richard Lugar Conservative
Daniel Coats Conservative
Chuck Grassley Leftist
Thomas Harkin Leftist
Charles Roberts Conservative
Jerry Moran Conservative
Mitch McConnell Conservative
Rand Paul Conservative
Mary Landrieu Leftist
David Vitter Conservative
Olympia Snowe Conservative
Susan Collins Conservative
Barbara Mikulski Leftist
Benjamin Cardin Leftist
John Kerry Conservative
Scott Brown Conservative
Carl Levin Leftist
Debbie Stabenow Leftist
Amy Klobuchar Leftist
Al Franken Leftist
William Cochran Leftist
Roger Wicker Conservative
Claire McCaskill Leftist
Roy Blunt Conservative
Max Baucus Conservative
Jon Tester Leftist
Earl Nelson Leftist
Mike Johanns Conservative
Harry Reid Leftist
Dean Heller Leftist
Jeanne Shaheen Leftist
Kelly Ayotte Conservative
Frank Lautenberg Did Not Vote
Robert Menendez Leftist
Jesse Bingaman Jr. Leftist
Thomas Udall Leftist
Charles Schumer Leftist
Kirsten Gillibrand Leftist
Richard Burr Conservative
Kay Hagan Leftist
Kent Conrad Leftist
John Hoeven Leftist
Sherrod Brown Leftist
Rob Portman Conservative
Jim Inhofe Conservative
Thomas Coburn Conservative
Ron Wyden Leftist
Jeff Merkley Leftist
Robert Casey, Jr. Leftist
Pat Toomey Conservative
Jack Reed Leftist
Sheldon Whitehouse Leftist
Lindsey Graham Conservative
James Demint Conservative
Timothy Johnson Leftist
John Thune Conservative
Lamar Alexander Conservative
Robert Corker Conservative
Kathryn Hutchison Leftist
John Cornyn Conservative
Orrin Hatch Did Not Vote
Mike Lee Conservative
Patrick Leahy Leftist
Bernard Sanders Leftist
James Webb Conservative
Mark Warner Conservative
Patty Murray Leftist
Maria Cantwell Leftist
John Rockefeller IV Leftist
Joe Manchin, III Leftist
Herbert Kohl Leftist
Ron Johnson Conservative
Michael Enzi Conservative
John Barrasso Conservative

CPAC

Fortress for Freedom, The Home of CPAC

515 King Street, Suite 300

Alexandria, VA 22314

Copyright © 2026 CPAC Partners and Affiliates, Conservative Political Action Coalition, Conservative Political Action Coalition Foundation. All rights reserved. The CPAC name, logos, trademarks, service marks, trade dress, and related intellectual property are owned by or licensed and are used with permission and may be used only with prior written permission. Conservative Political Action Coalition and Conservative Political Action Coalition Foundation are Wyoming nonprofit corporations with offices located at the Fortress for Freedom.

© 2026 CPAC · Follow @CPAC